Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Science vs. intuition

The human body is a deeply intricate machine, chemically complex beyond human understanding. Medical science has recently made significant progress, but constantly shifting nutritional recommendations and rising prevalence of chronic diseases suggest we only know a diminutive fraction of the truth. As an example, all fats used to be condemned as an overarching rule, and now certain fats are praised as a necessary part of an optimal diet (link, link, link). There is a current trend of avoiding grains    the so-called "paleo" diet, supported by "science"    although many fitness professionals are now saying that it's not all it's cracked up to be (link, another link, and one more link). In the midst of ever-changing recommendations about the latest and greatest diets and supplements, how are we supposed to know what to eat? It can be tempting to buy all the hottest new supplements and follow the latest diets, planning fitness regimens down to the utter minutiae and spending a whole lot of money doing it. Let me suggest a principle to help guide you through the whirlwind of often contradictory fitness information: follow your instincts.

At first blush that may seem like a mere feel-good platitude, simplistically corny and definitely irrelevant in the Information Age. However, as demonstrated above, avalanches of information can be counterproductive. Scientists discover some very basic biochemical principles and suddenly fitness professionals are touting far-fetched theories and jumping to rash, wild conclusions. Research scientists are much less likely to be illogical than the general public, but even still there is a culture of isolationism. They discover a nutrient that's beneficial for human consumption    vitamin C, for example    and then isolate it, put it into a pill, and sell it at grocery stores. What they're missing it that nutrients never come by themselves. Any healthy, natural food source has an incomprehensibly complex nutritional profile. Each nutrient is in delicate ratio to all of the others, and humans are designed to eat them all at once. There is a logical reason to perform science in an isolationist fashion, and that is because it's a productive, relatively easy way to study nutrition. We've learned a lot from such isolationist research, and I'm in no way denying that there are many instances when taking a chemically isolated pill of a single nutrient can help specific health conditions. But, as mentioned above, we've hardly even scratched the surface of biochemical complexity. We really don't know very much at all.

We don't consciously know much, that is. Humans have been coevolving with plants and animals for millions of years. We wouldn't have made it this far without developing acute instincts about what is good to eat and what isn't. Look at a carrot and tell me you don't know, deep inside, that it's good for you. Millions of years of evolution are telling you that that carrot is full of nutrients and vitamins that are good for your body. Does that mean you instinctively know the chemical composition and nutrient profile of a carrot? Far from it, but you still know that it's good for you. Of course, a lifetime of eating a modern diet full of highly-processed sugar, sodium, and fat has probably removed your desire to eat that carrot, but you can't look me in the eye and tell me that you honestly believe the carrot is bad for you. If you do, you're lying. The same goes with spinach, apples, rice, and so forth.

There is an important distinction to be made here. Do you enjoy eating ice cream, Oreos, and soda? If you're like the vast majority of the western world, you'll say yes. Do they taste good? Again, yes. But when you are eating that ice cream, you know, deep down, that it's not good for you. If they're not good in significant doses, why do our bodies crave sugar, fat, and salt? It's pretty well-explained here, here, here, and here, so I won't dive into the details. What you need to know for the purposes of this discussion is the difference between short- and long-term nutritional gratification, and the ways in which your bodies respond to both. Let me explain. Eating an Oreo tastes good. Eating twelve Oreos tastes even better. While eating them, you're in heaven. But ten minutes after eating a dozen Oreos, how do you feel? Definitely no better than before, and likely a whole lot worse. If you have even a semblance of a dietary conscience, you'll feel guilty on top of feeling a little sick. You might even be trying to convince yourself that you deserved the binge, while never being able to shake the reality that you know you didn't. Contrast that with the experience of eating a salad. While you're eating it, you may be thinking it tastes boring. You might even be thinking it tastes gross and a little grassy. But nobody needs to tell you that those vegetables are doing great things for every system in your body. You don't know what they're doing, or why, but you know that it's happening. Then, ten minutes after eating that salad (barring an inexplicable allergy to lettuce), you're feeling fine. Great, in fact. You feel good about yourself because you ate something so healthy. You might have liked that happy feeling so much you want another.

These cues, the knowledge you have deep down about whether food is healthy or not, should not be ignored. They are well-tuned, ancient signals so often ignored in western culture because they don't provide instant gratification. But when you stop and think about your long-term health, instant gratification becomes instantly irrelevant. Healthy eating provides many significant benefits we know of (cancer prevention, heart disease prevention, diabetes prevention, etc.), and given our very introductory knowledge of human health, it's possible    probable, in fact     that healthy eating gives us many benefits we don't even know of.

Does "healthy eating" mean all we ever do is listen to our instincts, eating what, when, and where we please, regardless of scientific evidence? No. Through thousands of rigorous, peer-reviewed studies, science has done wonderful things for our nutritional understanding, and has established certain principles we know to be true for the general population: Eat a wide variety of grains, vegetables, and fruits. Eat meat sparingly, especially red meat. Avoid all processed foods. Avoid added, processed sugars and unnatural (trans) fats. Eat natural foods that have been treated with minimal chemical herbicides, pesticides, and fertilizers. There are other guidelines out there, and the recommendations can change slightly depending on individual health conditions, but the big ideas remain the same. Within that framework, however, there is huge inherent flexibility. That is where instinct comes in. Don't leave up your portion sizes and food scheduling up to science. That would be silly. Science is good at establishing broad principles, but you are the master of your individual health. Listen to what your body is telling you. Don't listen to the part of you (the part that wants instant gratification) that tells you things you know to be false    like "sugar is good" and "cucumbers are bad"    but listen to what you know to be your honest, accurate conscience, and then apply that conscience within the broad, scientifically-proven framework.

Don't want to eat a salad today? The world won't end if you skip a day, or even a week. Sick of smoothies? Have some soup instead. Do you, like me, absolutely despise sweet corn? Then never eat it (that's my solution, anyway). Not up for going to the gym today? Stay home. Your muscles won't shrink in 24 hours. Are salads, smoothies, sweet corn, and gyms good? Yes. Are they good for you, personally, at any time of any day? Not necessarily. Of course, this doesn't mean you should make excuses when they aren't warranted. If you are legitimately concerned about injuring yourself by overworking, stay home from the gym. If you're just being lazy, then get your bum off the couch and work out. Do you not want to pushups because they're hard, or because you're concerned about aggravating that shoulder injury? Do you not want to go on a run because you'll get sweaty, or because you've been feeling the flu coming on and you don't want to hurt your immune system? Maybe your tummy feels gross when you eat peanuts, but you want the health benefits so you're taking the hit. Why would you do that? There's no need. There are tens of thousands of types of food. Try an alternative! Deep down, you know the difference between excuses and prudence. You don't need someone else to tell you. Furthermore, you shouldn't put 100% trust in a fitness professional's    or even a scientific committee's    recommendation for the latest and greatest supplements or diet plans. Don't want to eat GMO plants, even though there are studies suggesting there are no negative health effects? You don't need to back up every health choice you make with scientific papers. If you feel strongly, internally guided to make a decision, then make it. If you are going to try to recommend a specific course of action for someone else, then recall this post. Maybe what's good for you isn't good for someone else. Your gut might tell you that GMO foods are bad for you, and it's best for your own personal body machine to avoid them, but that doesn't guarantee your neighbor will be so affected (or vice versa).

Do research, learn unbiased facts, and then plan your exercise, diet, and supplementation according to both those facts and that inner compass of what health means for you. Take charge of your health. Tailor your fitness.