Genetically Modified Organisms, or GMOs, are becoming increasingly commonplace in modern American agriculture. To keep things brief here, I'll let you Google around and learn about the history of GMOs for yourself, if you're interested. From here on I'll assume you have a basic idea of what GMOs are.
The broad scientific consensus is that GMOs are safe for human consumption (1,783 studies show just that; click here and here). However, there is a definite (although minority) segment of the population that firmly believes GMOs are unhealthy, even dangerous. In fact, no solid evidence for GMOs harming human health has ever been presented. Why on earth am I writing about them, then? There are two main reasons.
1. Due to patent and intellectual property laws, anyone who buys genetically modified seeds from a biotech company (the only way to get them) must sign an agreement that restricts how the buyer can use the seeds, including seed research. This means that the seed company can veto anything scientists want to publish about the plants. Obviously, the seed company has a vested interest in making their products look good, so they only approve research projects that make their products look good. In fact, these biotech companies will personally and professionally threaten scientists who don't make their products look good, according to the chief scientist at The Organic Center.
In a nutshell, the seed companies solely control research about the safety of their own seeds. This means there is no third-party verification whatsoever. I don't need to explain why this is not a good thing.
(Source links: Scientific American and Seed Magazine)
2. Just because a food doesn't cause serious human health problems in 90 days doesn't mean it's good for us. It is well-established that cancer, diabetes, heart disease, and so on are massively affected by diet. However, foods that greatly increase risk of those diseases (diets high in sugar, trans fat, processed meat, and so forth) don't give people those diseases in three months. Not even three years. Sometimes it takes sixty years or more for bad diet habits to catch up with people, but catch up they still do. Scientists have learned this in large part thanks to massive cohort studies that generally spanned multiple decades. A lot of the GMO studies (I didn't have time to read all 1,783 of them to get an exact count) didn't run for more than a few months. In fact, in all my research I've never heard of a large-scale, long-term study of GMOs. I'm talking at least five years, preferably ten or more, with more than ten thousand human participants. Maybe even try a few dozen chimpanzees or rats (allowing more ethical randomized controlled trials), but still letting the study run through significant portions of the animals' lifespans. Even after that study, it would be necessary for other scientists to repeat the experiment for verification, as well as expanding on principles and asking related questions.
Between restrictions and relatively tiny time-scales, there is a serious gap in the claim that GMOs are safe for human consumption. When it comes to GMOs, we should not take an attitude of "innocent until proven guilty." Scientists engineer plants that produce their own pesticide and then feed these plants to us and nobody sees a problem with that? When it comes to genetic modification, more (unrestricted) research needs to be done to actually establish GMO safety before we can conclude that GMO safety has been established.
Disclaimer: I'm not saying that GMOs cause cancer, or anything similarly extreme. Any such link hasn't been established, and claiming it has would be ridiculous. All I'm saying is that we need to do more to make sure what we're putting into our mouths is good for us. We need to ask questions and take charge of our health. Maybe GMOs aren't bad for us at all. Maybe certain kinds are and certain kinds aren't. We really can't know until we do quality, long-term studies. But claiming that GMOs are sabotaging the health of millions, like some health activists say, would be just as illogical as claiming that GMOs have been proven to be safe for human consumption.
Another disclaimer: It's 12:30 am. I didn't proofread this. I apologize in advance.
Exactly! I was just having a conversation with a friend about ethics in research. There is literally research to support any and everything. The truth of the "research" is the question. Always question the agenda of the researcher, like the food pyramid sponsored by the meat and dairy industry. To find the truth, due diligence is needed, balancing the secular knowledge of experts with intuitive snd spiritual knowledge. Reliance on one or the other is only being partially informed.
ReplyDelete